As VPN use becomes more and more mainstream, the number of features on offer keeps growing.
While VPNs used to be for techies looking to enhance their online privacy, today VPNs are used for streaming, to block ads, and to punch through certain stubborn firewalls.
This also has the collateral effect of making it more difficult to assess the value of a VPN provider.
So in this post, we put Private Internet Access and Windscribe VPN head to head in a detailed comparison, covering security features as well as convenience features, to see which one we can recommend over the other.
Windscribe VPN vs Private Internet Access - Side By Side
|Name||Private Internet Access||Windscribe|
|User Friendliness Score||9||9|
|Price per month (cheapest)||$2.69||$4.08|
|Allows torrenting / P2P||Yes||Yes|
|Refund Period||30 Days||3 Days|
|Desktop Operating Software||Windows, MacOS, Linux||Windows, MacOS, Linux|
|Mobile Apps||iOS, Android||iOS, Android|
|VPN Protocols||IKEv2, OpenVPN, WireGuard, L2TP/IPSec, PPTP||IKEv2, OpenVPN, WireGuard|
|DNS Leak Protection||Yes||Yes|
|Logging Policy||No-logging Policy||No-logging Policy|
|Out of 14 eyes||No||No|
|Sign-up Information Required||Only Valid Email||Username/password|
|Avg. Ping NY||28.33 ms||65 ms|
|Avg. Download NY||Over a 100 Mbps Network (Download): 94.35 Mbps||Over a 100 Mbps Network (Download): 95.36 Mbps|
|Avg. Upload NY||Over a 30 Mbps Network (Upload): 25.05 Mbps||Over a 30 Mbps Network (Upload): 26.54 Mbps|
Can't choose between Windscribe or Private Internet Access?
Both Private Internet Access and Windscribe are high-quality VPN providers, who take a strong stance on user privacy.
They both offer compelling features, both relative to privacy and convenience. This means, secure VPN protocols, strong ciphers, lo-logging in-tunnel DNS servers, ads & tracker blocking and, of course, a robust no-logging policy.
And, as far as PIA is concerned, their no-logging policy was (successfully) put to the test in 2016. PIA also passed an independent security audit in 2018.
However, PIA was recently acquired by Kape Technologies, a company with a questionable past in the AdTech industry - and that made some PIA users uncomfortable.
Windscribe doesn’t have issues related to their ownership structure, nor have they had the opportunity to prove their privacy claims, yet Windscribe is still a young player in the VPN space.
All in all, I think this comparison will be a very close one. And to be clear, I feel both these VPN providers are excellent choices.
Let's start our in this Private Internet Access vs. Windscribe comparison by looking at speed. Whether or not you’re using a VPN, speed is going to be important to you.
Any VPN will cause somewhat of a slowdown, but it should be as small as possible. Let’s see how PIA and Windscribe compare on speed.
Private Internet Access
Tested on a 100Mbps (Download) and 30Mbps (Upload) network
Server: U.S.A., New York
Average Download Speed: 94.35Mbps
Average Upload Speed: 25.05Mbps
Tested on a 100Mbps (Download) and 30Mbps (Upload) network
Server: U.S.A., New York
Average Download Speed: 95.36Mbps
Average Upload Speed: 26.54Mbps
As usual, we’re looking at the difference between my official ISP bandwidth and the results of these speed tests.
Now, I’ve been doing VPN reviews and comparisons for a while now, and I think this is the closest I’ve seen two VPN providers come on speed. The results on upload and download are almost identical.
So the speed dip on download is so small as to be imperceptible over both providers’ networks.
And it’s the same deal on upload, though the speed dip is slightly more significant on upload.
But upload speed is always lower that download because ISPs provide many more download channels than upload channels.
There’s just no way to distinguish these providers on speed. A tie it is.
User-friendliness has become a major concern for VPN service providers, in recent years.
As more and more people turn to VPNs, providers need to make sure that new, less technical users are able to use their services without being overwhelmed.
Private Internet Access and Windscribe both supply native client applications on all major platforms. And they both provide unlimited bandwidth.
PIA and Windscribe both support:
- Chrome/Firefox/Opera Browser Extensions
And Windscribe also provides native clients for the Nvidia Shield and KODI platforms.
I didn't need to contact customer support for either of these VPN services. Everything just worked vey well from the start.
As far as simultaneous connections go, PIA allows a generous 10 simultaneous connections, while Windscribe places no limit at all on the number of devices that can simultaneously connect to their network using the same account.
Let’s be clear here. I’m giving the point to Windscribe just because they go that extra mile over PIA. But PIA’s offering here should be considered extremely user-friendly. Allowing 10 simultaneous connections is way above what most allow in the VPN industry. And their coverage, in terms of native apps, is also excellent.
Streaming over a VPN connection is beneficial on a few levels. You get the following benefits:
- The security benefit of a fully encrypted connection
- Avoiding ISP bandwidth throttling
- Circumventing geo-restrictions
And as you probably know, unblocking Netflix access has become a priority for many VPN providers, since the Netflix VPN ban that started in 2018.
While Private Internet Access claims they are streaming-friendly in their marketing materials, they cannot bypass the Netflix VPN ban.
But bear in mind that PIA defines itself as a privacy company more than a media unblocking service.
Windscribe, on the other hand, was able to bypass the ban easily. However, be warned that according to some reviews out there, Windscribe does not work with Netflix.
I believe this has more to do with the server IP addresses being blacklisted at the time those reviewers tried it. Had they performed their tests a few days earlier or later, it may well have worked.
Nevertheless, in my tests, Netflix over Windscribe worked very well. No buffering, no lag, no problem.
Windscribe (obviously) gets the point here. PIA simply does not unblock Netflix.
4. Security & Encryption
Private Internet Access and CyberGhost VPN both support secure VPN protocols.
Private Internet Access supports:
Windscribe VPN supports:
Both providers also support the industry-standard cipher: AES-256.
However, WireGuard uses more modern and perhaps more secure ciphers:
So both providers support secure VPN protocols: IKEv2/IPSec, OpenVPN, and the new WireGuard protocol. Good stuff.
However, PIA also supports the weak and obsolete L2TP/IPSec and PPTP protocols.
As I write each time I see a provider supporting these protocols: weak and obsolete protocols should not be supported by commercial VPN services.
It puts less technical users are at risk, who may use these protocols thinking they are secure. These protocols should be phased out.
The point goes to Windscribe here. They only support secure VPN protocols. You can’t shoot yourself in the foot.
5. Logs & Privacy
Both Private Internet Access and Windscribe VPN commit to a strong no-logging policy. But how do they communicate this in their privacy policies?
While we know that Private Internet Access doesn’t make a big splash about their no-logging policy in their marketing (though they do mention it), they’ve actually proved that they don’t log in a real-world case.
However, looking at TorrentFreak’s Which VPN Providers Really Take Anonymity Seriously in 2020? guide, PIA makes the following statement concerning logging:
"We do not store any logs relating to traffic, session, DNS or metadata. There are no logs for any person or entity to match an IP address and a timestamp to a current or former user of our service. In summary, we do not log, period. Privacy is our policy.”
It is likely to mitigate abuse, but other VPN providers are able to achieve that goal without logging timestamps. We hope to see Windscribe move in that direction n in the near future.
Winner: Private Internet Access
We’re going to turn our attention to price now. Below is a list of the different packages, prices, and accepted payment methods for Private Internet Access and Windscribe VPN:
Private Internet AccessVisit Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access offers three subscription terms:
- 9.95 USD for one month of service
- 39.95 USD for one year of service (works out to 3.33 USD per month)
- 69.95 USD for two years of service (works out to 2.69 USD per month)
- Credit card
- Amazon pay
- Many cryptocurrencies, including Bitcoin
All of PIA’s subscriptions come with a 30-day money-back guarantee.
WindscribeVisit Windcribe VPN
Windscribe offers three types of subscription and takes an innovative approach in offering their subscription plans.:
- 9.00 USD for one month of service
- 49.00 USD for one year of service (works out to 4.08 USD per month)
- 1 USD per active server on their ‘Build Your Own Plan’ plan. With this plan, you choose the servers you want to have access to and you build your custom plan at 1$ per server.
Windscribe also offers a (very good) free version that gives you 10GBs of data transfer over 10 different VPN servers per month.
Windscribe’s plans come with a 3-day money-back guarantee. Yes, that 3, not 30. It does seem odd. But one could argue that if you simply want to try Windscribe, just go for the free plan.
Now, in comparing these two providers, it appears that Private Internet Access is cheaper than Windscribe, although the ‘Build A Plan’ option is hard to compare because it all depends on the number of servers you want access to.
And while PIA doesn’t have a free option, they do provide you with a 30-day refund period, as opposed to Windscribe’s 3.
I would make it a tie here. While their offerings differ, I feel they end up balancing each other out.
Like most VPN providers, Private Internet Access and Windscribe VPN both support torrenting. And they support it extremely well.
However, both PIA and Windscribe don’t really mention torrenting in their marketing.
With PIA, simply connect to any server and you should be torrenting within seconds.
Windscribe, though again, they don’t mention torrenting all that much, provide dedicated P2P servers.
They are marked in Windscribe’s apps. Or, to be more exact, the servers that don’t support P2P are marked within the app.
So the vast majority of Windscribe servers are P2P-friendly.
This will have to be another tie. There aren’t enough differences to distinguish them on the torrenting front.
8. Other Features
This will be a difficult one. Both providers do offer other features than the ones mentioned in this post. But they often tend to be the same features.
Does PIA or Windscribe support split-tunnelling: the ability to selectively route traffic through the VPN or through your ISP? Yes, both of them do.
Does PIA or Windscribe provide an ads & tracker blocker? Yes, both of them do.
But we were able to find this:
Windscribe supports multiple server hops (but in a slightly convoluted way…)
- Multiple Server Hops: Windscribe supports multiple server hops. That means that when connected to Windscribe’s network, you have the possibility of bouncing your VPN traffic over multiple other VPN servers, making you that much harder to identify. However, to achieve this on Windscribe’s network you need to use their browser extension on top of the VPN connection. So you connect to a VPN server using the Desktop app (this will not work on mobile) and then, using the browser extension, you connect to another VPN server. This also means that only your browser traffic goes over the second hop. The rest of your traffic goes through the single server of the desktop app.
I simply don’t feel that it’s enough for Windscribe to get the point here. And their implementation of multi-hop is not optimal. I think a tie here is fair.
Conclusion: Private Internet Access vs Windscribe VPN
So who wins?
We had eight categories:
We attribute one point to the winner in each category. And both providers get a point in the event of a tie.
The breakdown looks like this:
- Speed - (Tie)
- User-Friendliness - (Windscribe)
- Streaming - (Windscribe)
- Security & Encryption - (Windscribe)
- Logs and Privacy - (PIA)
- Pricing - (Tie)
- Torrenting - (Tie)
- Other Features - (Tie)
So that’s 5 points for Private Internet Access and 7 points for Windscribe VPN.
I actually thought the results would be closer than this. But I do feel Windscribe deserves to win. But this is by no means a blowout.
And in many instances, Windscribe gets the point simply by etching ever so slightly over Private Internet Access.
To be clear: these are two excellent VPN providers for privacy, security, and convenience.
Both are recommended.
Private Internet Access
Go With Private Internet Access if:
- You want a trustworthy VPN provider, with a proven track record.
- You want to save a few bucks while still getting a high-quality VPN service.
- You don’t need to use a VPN with Netflix.
Go With Windscribe VPN if:
- You want a trustworthy VPN provider.
- You want to stream Netflix over your VPN.
- You want to build your own subscription plan.
Thanks for reading!
Windscribe Vs. Private Internet Access - Side By Side
By Marc Dahan
Last updated: September 17, 2020